Microsoft has fixed most of RRoD problems now and even if your console gets it, Microsoft will fix it for Free whether or not you have a valid warrenty. How does you not being a CoD fan mean you don't like the 360? It came out for both consoles. And if that is what everyone is playing than I would go with the console that has a better online experiance. I do agree Battlefield Bad Company 2 will be beast but I don't think it will overcome MW or MW2 (IMO).