please rate 1-10

[HavocMarine]

Ok...i just want some constructive criticism...no flaming..
just keep in mind these are really old and yes i know i suck...just want to know wut yall think....i might start doing gfx again..

Rate 1-10 and tell me how to improve








Request
V

[XzZombiexX]

Overall: 6
Your main problem is depth, make sure the details you add flow perfectly with the theme you chose for your sig
Another thing is blending, make sure that everything looks like it belongs there, and that everything perfectly fits in with each other.
Last, text. Seems like the hardest thing for people, even me sometimes, to grasp is adding text to signatures. Just like everything else, it needs to have a depth all of it's own. Don't worry about adding too much detail to text, but make it fit in. For example, use clipping masks. btw, make sure the font used is not too heavy it should be simple.

Hope you found some relevant stuff in there. If so, please rep+

[HavocMarine]

Overall: 6
Your main problem is depth, make sure the details you add flow perfectly with the theme you chose for your sig
Another thing is blending, make sure that everything looks like it belongs there, and that everything perfectly fits in with each other.
Last, text. Seems like the hardest thing for people, even me sometimes, to grasp is adding text to signatures. Just like everything else, it needs to have a depth all of it's own. Don't worry about adding too much detail to text, but make it fit in. For example, use clipping masks. btw, make sure the font used is not too heavy it should be simple.

Hope you found some relevant stuff in there. If so, please rep+

Thx...yeah i agree with you, but not sure if its an overll 6...maybe like a 5 or 4 1/2....

these are all old...ima try to come up with some new stuff..

[Blue]

Overall: 6
Your main problem is depth, make sure the details you add flow perfectly with the theme you chose for your sig
Another thing is blending, make sure that everything looks like it belongs there, and that everything perfectly fits in with each other.
Last, text. Seems like the hardest thing for people, even me sometimes, to grasp is adding text to signatures. Just like everything else, it needs to have a depth all of it's own. Don't worry about adding too much detail to text, but make it fit in. For example, use clipping masks. btw, make sure the font used is not too heavy it should be simple.

Hope you found some relevant stuff in there. If so, please rep+

i agree.Depth and blending.

[mtt365]

I give it a 5.8

[gokickadogx2]

Like like all except the T-Pain and the chainsaw one.
6

[azaiscool]

your all harsh lol i give it a 7 or 7 1/2 keep up with the good work

[ijustposted]

i give it a 6

[SyKotik Cannon]

8

nice dude